6 Major Difference Between 3PL and 4PL
Table of Contents
What is 3pl and 4pl?
Modern supply chains require outside partners for business organizations to streamline their logistics operations. The supply chain solutions that stand out most frequently in operations include 3PL (Third-Party Logistics) combined with 4PL (Fourth-Party Logistics).
These two supply chain optimization methods differ in their operational levels even though they share the same goal. Knowledge of the fundamental differences between 3PL and 4PL serves organizations seeking to develop sophisticated logistics plans.
What is 3PL - Third Party Logistics?
3PL AND 4PL – Difference between 3pl and 4pl
In a 3PL model, an enterprise maintains management oversight, but outsources operations of transportation and logistics to a provider who may subcontract out some or all of the execution.
The 3PL model is where a manufacturer maintains oversight of their supply chain but outsources their transportation and logistics operations to a 3PL provider.
Most of the time, a 3PL will be receiving, handling, storing and delivering your goods. Usually, they will do so under the name of your business not theirs. This isn’t a large distinction for many companies but is an important one for some.
What Does a 3PL Company Specialize In?
3PL companies tend to specialize in:
Transportation: Managing freight movement via road, rail, air, and sea, which is particularly relevant for businesses navigating diverse geography.
Warehousing: Providing storage solutions, inventory management, and order fulfillment centers, crucial for managing stock across varied markets.
Distribution: Handling the movement of goods from warehouses to end customers, a vital aspect of reaching a vast consumer base.
Freight Forwarding: Arranging the shipment of goods internationally, important for businesses engaged in import and export.
Customs Brokerage: Assisting with customs clearance processes, a necessary step for international trade.
All of the above third party logistics services are scaled and customized to a client’s requirements. One client may not require warehousing, whereas another will, which is why 3PL companies are adept at providing different services to different clients. The services offered by a 3PL company can include all of the above, more, or even as few as one.
3PL AND 4PL – Difference between 3pl and 4pl
What is 4PL - Fourth Party Logistics?
In a 4PL model, an enterprise outsources management of logistics activities as well as the execution across the supply chain. The 4PL provider typically offers more strategic insight and management over the enterprise’s supply chain.
Fourth-party logistics, also known as 4PL or lead logistics providers, is a logistics model in which manufacturers outsource both the organization and oversight of their supply chain to a 4PL provider.
4PL generally offer a high level of effective supply chain management to customers, allowing manufacturers to outsource their logistical process to third-party professionals in order to manage it efficiently.
What Does a 4PL Company Specialize In?
4PL companies tend to provide (generally through 3PL partners):
Supply Chain Design and Consulting: Offering expertise to design and optimize your entire supply chain strategy, considering the unique challenges and opportunities within the market.
End-to-End Management: Overseeing all aspects of your supply chain, from sourcing raw materials to delivering finished goods to customers.
Technology Integration: Leveraging advanced technology and data analytics to provide visibility, optimize processes, and make strategic decisions for your operations.
Vendor Management: Managing relationships and contracts with multiple 3PL providers, ensuring seamless integration and optimal performance across your logistics network.
Focus on Optimization and Efficiency: Their primary goal is to drive overall efficiency, reduce costs, and improve the agility of your entire supply chain.
6 Major Difference between 3pl and 4pl
The main difference between 3PL and 4PL is that a 4PL handles the entirety of a supply chain while a 3PL is mainly concerned with handling just the logistical process.
Difference between 3pl and 4pl is hotly debated between companies these days as to which model is superior. Ultimately, each one works better for different situations and understanding how their differ is crucial for every company.
The main difference between 3PL and 4PL is that a 4PL handles the entirety of a supply chain while a 3PL is mainly concerned with handling just the logistical process.
3PL and 4PL is hotly debated between companies these days as to which model is superior. Ultimately, each one works better for different situations and understanding how their differ is crucial for every company.
1. Scope
3PL
A 3PL (Third-Party Logistics) provider specializes in managing particular operational duties that specifically serve a company’s supply chain operations. The 3PL provider helps companies execute transportation services and offers warehousing solutions with inventory storage capability and distribution management for product delivery to customers. Their responsibilities extend only to the contracted outsourced operational activities.
4PL
The 4PL (Fourth-Party Logistics) provider handles a comprehensive range of supply chain activities by overseeing the entire client supply chain process, starting from raw material sourcing through to product delivery. The organisation has the authority to oversee and develop strategies for all logistical aspects.
2. Asset Ownership
3PL
The delivery of 3PL services depends on tangible assets, which 3PL companies maintain as part of their operation. The ownership of trucks and operational control of warehouses and technology platforms represent key assets that 3PL providers can use to deliver their services. The direct ownership provides 3PL companies with complete control of their resources.
4PL
4PL providers function independently from physical logistics asset ownership, while 3PL companies maintain ownership of their logistics assets. The main advantage of 4PL providers rests in their capability to expertly manage multiple external service providers, including 3PL, for delivering optimised supply chain solutions to their clients.
3. Relationship
3PL
The business connection between companies and 3PL providers operates through transactional arrangements. The main objective centres on delivering contracted logistics services with efficiency and effectiveness. The fundamental aspect of this professional connection remains the accomplishment of assigned duties even though a solid work relationship provides benefits.
4PL
A strategic partnership defines the connection between a company and its 4PL provider. Through an extension of internal management teams, the 4PL develops a deep understanding of business objectives before designing supply chain structures that support organisational targets. The relationship demands enhanced levels of collaboration, together with deep trust between both parties.
4. Integration
3PL
A 3PL provider dedicates its services to work inside a particular area of its clients’ logistics operations, which fall under its management responsibility. A transportation 3PL will merge its tracking technology with the client’s order system to show real-time movement of shipments.
4PL
A 4PL provider adopts an all-encompassing method for integration. The 4PL provider establishes seamless connections between all supply chain components by uniting different service providers such as 3PLs, technology platforms, and relevant entities. This unified integration system works to establish an efficient end-to-end process.
5. Focus
3PL
The primary focus of a 3PL provider is on achieving operational efficiency within the specific logistics functions they handle. Their key performance indicators often revolve around metrics like on-time delivery rates, warehouse utilization, and cost-effectiveness within their defined service area.
4PL
The strategic optimization and total supply chain efficiency form the main focus of a 4PL provider. 4PL providers aim to minimise complete supply chain expenses while making logistical processes more flexible and adaptive and increasing total system visibility and constantly improving every logistical activity from end to end.
6. Technology
3PL
The particular services that 3PL providers execute through technology include transportation management systems or warehouse management systems.
4PL
4PL providers leverage more advanced and comprehensive technology platforms. These often include sophisticated analytics tools, supply chain visibility platforms, and integration capabilities that allow them to gain a holistic view of the entire supply chain. This enables them to identify optimization opportunities, make data-driven decisions, and provide strategic insights to their clients across all aspects of their logistics network.
Conclusion
The management of business goods falls under the domain of both 3PL and 4PL services. The function of a 3PL service is comparable to hiring professional movers to execute particular operations such as distribution and warehousing while maintaining overall control. A 4PL functions as a logistics manager who oversees the complete delivery system while selecting optimal companies including 3PLs for efficient performance.
Leave a Replay
Recent Posts
